Goodwill Shoppers Say They Can No Longer Afford to Shop There

For years, Goodwill has been a go-to destination for people looking to stretch their budgets. Whether you needed clothes for your growing children, furniture for your first apartment, or everyday household essentials, buying secondhand was often an affordable alternative to shopping retail.

But some longtime Goodwill shoppers say that’s changing. In a recent discussion on Reddit, shoppers expressed frustration over rising prices, declining inventory quality, and the difficulty of finding genuine bargains.

For some, shopping at Goodwill has become a luxury they can no longer afford.

fishers august 2025 goodwill store Depositphotos 837342680 L
Image Credit: Deposit Photos

Buying New Is Sometimes Cheaper Than Buying Used

One of the biggest frustrations for shoppers is finding donated items priced close to, or even above, their original retail value. Some say they’re better off shopping the clearance racks at stores like Ross and Target, where they can purchase brand-new merchandise for less.

“I can’t afford Goodwill anymore. Its cheaper at Target,” one shopper wrote.

Others admitted to regularly looking up products on their phones while shopping at Goodwill. They’re not necessarily looking for items to resell but simply checking whether they’re getting a reasonable deal.

Shoppers Say the Good Finds Are Becoming Harder to Come By

It’s not just the prices that are frustrating shoppers. Some longtime customers say they’re finding fewer quality clothing items, electronics, collectibles, and other desirable merchandise on store shelves.

“Goodwill always used to be a place where I could find items that I normally could not afford,” the original poster explained.

Some shoppers believe Goodwill’s online auction platform is partly responsible, as certain valuable donations are sold online rather than being made available in stores. Others speculate that more people are selling their unwanted belongings themselves instead of donating them.

Some Shoppers Are Taking Their Business Elsewhere

Frustrated by prices, some shoppers say they’ve stopped visiting Goodwill altogether. Instead, they’re shopping at church-run thrift stores, independent charity shops, garage sales, and secondhand marketplaces like Vinted and Facebook Marketplace.

Some are also reconsidering where they donate their belongings, choosing smaller organizations that support causes within their communities, such as animal shelters and hospice care.

Others recommend visiting Goodwill outlet stores, where many items are sold by the pound at significantly lower prices.

Is Goodwill Still Worth Shopping At?

Not every Goodwill shopper has had the same experience. Goodwill operates through independently managed regional organizations, meaning prices, inventory, and discounts can vary considerably depending on where you live.

Bargains still exist, but it pays to compare prices, shop discount days, and explore other secondhand stores in your area.

Other Posts You Might Like

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *