If you’ve held onto a box of old vinyl records for years, there’s a chance you have more than a few favorites sitting in there. Most records aren’t worth much, but certain pressings have become highly collectible and can sell for far more than their original price.
The interesting part is that the album itself isn’t always what drives the value. First pressings, canceled releases, promotional copies, rare cover versions, and unusual mistakes can make one copy worth much more than another copy of the exact same album.
Before you clear out that old record collection or take everything to a yard sale, check what you’ve got. One of these releases could be hiding among the more ordinary records.
Stonewall | Stonewall (1976)
This obscure psychedelic rock album has a bizarre history that has made it a favorite among record collectors. Very few original copies are believed to have circulated, which is why genuine examples can command thousands of dollars.
Related: Streaming Took Over Music. It Still Couldn’t Kill CDs and Vinyl
Röyksopp | Melody A.M. (2001)
Most copies of Melody A.M. aren’t especially rare, but a small run features artwork by street artist Banksy. Those versions are much harder to find and have sold for thousands when they turn up for sale.
The Beatles | Yesterday and Today (1966)
The Beatles’ original “butcher cover” is one of the most recognizable oddities in record collecting. The cover was pulled after a public backlash, making untouched original copies especially desirable.
The Rolling Stones | Street Fighting Man (1968)
Some early copies of this release came with a picture sleeve showing police confronting protesters. The sleeve was withdrawn, and surviving copies with the original image have become sought-after collector’s items.
Related: What most people get wrong about thrifting
The Five Sharps | Stormy Weather (1952)
This doo-wop recording wasn’t a big hit at the time, but its rarity has given it a much bigger reputation among collectors. Only a very small number of original copies are known to exist, making one extremely hard to find.
The Velvet Underground | The Velvet Underground & Nico (1967)
The Velvet Underground’s debut has long been a favorite among collectors, but some early versions are far more valuable than later pressings. Label differences, alternate mixes, and promotional copies can all affect what a collector is willing to pay.
Frank Wilson | Do I Love You (Indeed I Do) (1965)
Frank Wilson’s Motown single was withdrawn soon after being pressed, leaving behind very few original copies. Those surviving records are among the rarest soul singles and have reached extremely high prices at auction.
Related: I Always Check for These Things When Thrifting for My Kids
Bob Dylan | The Freewheelin’ Bob Dylan (1963)
A small number of early copies included four songs that were later replaced before the album was widely released. Those earlier versions have become prized by Dylan collectors and can be worth far more than standard copies.
Tommy Johnson | Alcohol and Jake Blues (1930)
Early blues records can be difficult to find because so few copies survived over the decades. An original copy of this Tommy Johnson recording would be an extraordinary find for a serious music collector.
Prince | The Black Album (1987)
Prince canceled The Black Album shortly before its planned release, but some promotional copies had already been sent out. Those original 1987 pressings are much harder to find than the later official release and can be worth a lot more.
Aphex Twin | Caustic Window (Recorded 1994)
This unreleased electronic album was pressed in very limited numbers before being shelved. Its unusual history and extreme rarity have made it one of the most talked-about finds among electronic music collectors.
The Beatles | The Beatles (White Album) (1968)
Every original copy of The White Album received a serial number on the cover, and the earliest numbers are especially desirable to collectors. A very low number combined with excellent condition can make a copy considerably more valuable.
