Couple Buys Vince Lombardi’s Sweater at Goodwill for 58 Cents and Later Sells It for $43,020

If you’ve ever wondered whether valuable pieces of history are still hiding in thrift stores, this couple’s Goodwill discovery is proof that they are.

Sean and Rikki McEvoy purchased a vintage sweater for just 58 cents at a Goodwill Outlet in Asheville, North Carolina. Little did they know that it once belonged to legendary football coach Vince Lombardi.

According to Heritage Auctions, the sweater eventually sold for an incredible $43,020 at auction.

image 2

A Routine Trip to Goodwill Turned Into an Unexpected Discovery

The Tennessee couple regularly shopped at thrift stores to find merchandise for their vintage clothing business. During a visit to Goodwill, Sean spotted a black-and-gold sweater with the words “West Point” across the front.

He liked its appearance and quality but didn’t recognize its historical significance. Since the Goodwill Outlet sold clothing by weight, the sweater cost him less than a dollar.

“I picked it up and thought it was cool,” McEvoy told ESPN, as reported by ABC News. “At first, I thought it was a basketball warm-up.”

A Television Documentary Revealed the Sweater’s Possible History

Several months after the purchase, Sean was watching a documentary about Vince Lombardi when he noticed an old photograph of the football coach wearing a remarkably familiar sweater.

Rikki remembered seeing a name written on a small piece of fabric sewn inside their thrift store purchase. Upon closer inspection, the couple discovered the handwritten words “Lombardi 46.”

What they had initially considered an interesting piece of vintage sportswear suddenly had the potential to be something far more significant.

Experts Confirmed It Belonged to Vince Lombardi

Sean initially contacted the Pro Football Hall of Fame before approaching Heritage Auctions. Rather than risk shipping the potentially valuable sweater during the holiday season, he drove to Dallas to have it examined.

Sports memorabilia authentication company MEARS verified its authenticity. Historical photographs also showed Lombardi wearing the sweater during his time as an assistant football coach at West Point, where he worked from 1949 to 1953.

This was years before Lombardi became the celebrated head coach of the Green Bay Packers and the namesake of the Super Bowl trophy.

The Sweater Sold for More Than Twice Its Anticipated Value

Before the auction, experts suggested that the sweater could fetch around $20,000. However, collectors were willing to pay considerably more for this rare piece of football history.

On February 21, 2015, an anonymous telephone bidder won the sweater with a $36,000 bid. With the buyer’s premium included, the final auction price reached $43,020.

Not bad for a piece of clothing that originally cost the couple just 58 cents.

How the Valuable Sweater Ended Up at Goodwill

Unlike many valuable thrift store discoveries, this one had a traceable history. The sweater had been donated by Ann Wannamaker, whose late husband, Bill Wannamaker, worked alongside Lombardi on the West Point coaching staff.

In recognition of the family’s original charitable intentions, Heritage Auctions donated its entire seller’s commission, reported to be nearly $4,000, to Goodwill.

Although the organization initially sold the sweater for pocket change, it ultimately benefited from its remarkable auction result.

Other Posts You Might Like

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *