Some Buffalo Nickels Are Worth Thousands—Here Are 12 to Look For

The Buffalo Nickel is one of the most recognizable American coins ever made. First minted in 1913, it features a Native American portrait on the front and an American bison on the back. The design remained in use until 1938, leaving behind a coin series that collectors still enjoy searching for today.

Millions of Buffalo Nickels were produced over those years, so an old one isn’t automatically worth a fortune. Certain dates, mint marks, rare varieties, and unusual errors can make some examples worth hundreds or even thousands of dollars.

If you have an old coin jar, a family collection, or a handful of nickels tucked away in a drawer, these 12 Buffalo Nickels are worth a closer look.

Some Buffalo Nickels
Image Credit: Pexels

1935 Doubled Die Reverse Buffalo Nickel

The 1935 Doubled Die Reverse is an interesting variety because parts of the lettering and other details on the buffalo side appear doubled. This difference comes from a minting error and can make the coin stand out from an ordinary 1935 Buffalo Nickel.

Collectors look for clear, genuine doubling and a coin that’s still in good condition. Since minor marks or damage can sometimes be mistaken for a minting error, authentication is a good idea before assigning it a high value.

Related: The Most Valuable Pennies Still Hiding in Circulation Today

1931-S Buffalo Nickel

The 1931-S was struck at the San Francisco Mint during the Great Depression, with a much lower mintage than many other Buffalo Nickels. Its smaller production run makes it a date collectors often look for.

Finding one with plenty of detail is harder than finding a worn example. The buffalo’s high points and the Native American portrait tend to show wear quickly, so coins with sharper details usually attract more interest.

1936-D 3½ Legs Buffalo Nickel

The 1936-D 3½ Legs Buffalo Nickel gets its unusual name from the buffalo on the reverse. Excessive polishing of the coin die removed part of one of the animal’s front legs, leaving behind a small portion that gives the variety its distinctive appearance.

The missing leg makes this variety easier to recognize than some other minting errors. Coins with clear identifying details and little wear are generally more appealing to collectors.

1919-S Buffalo Nickel

The 1919-S was made at the San Francisco Mint, and finding one in excellent condition can be a challenge. Many examples circulated for years, leaving the date, portrait, and buffalo with noticeable wear.

Collectors pay close attention to the mint mark and how much detail remains visible on both sides. A well-preserved example can be worth considerably more than one that’s been heavily worn.

1924-D Buffalo Nickel

The 1924-D is a date worth checking, particularly if you come across one with strong details. Worn examples are easier to find, but coins in better condition are much harder to locate.

Some Buffalo Nickels from this period also have weak strikes, which can leave parts of the design looking faint even before circulation wear takes its toll. A clearly dated coin with good detail on the buffalo can be more appealing to collectors.

1917-D Buffalo Nickel

The 1917-D Buffalo Nickel was produced at the Denver Mint, and circulated examples can still turn up in older collections. Finding one with very little wear and well-defined details is a different matter.

Collectors look for sharp features on the Native American portrait and buffalo, along with attractive surfaces. Coins that retain much of their original mint luster are especially desirable.

1925-D Buffalo Nickel

The 1925-D is known for the weak strikes found on many examples. Some left the Mint with incomplete details, and years of circulation often made the date and other design features even harder to see.

A coin with a clearly readable date and unusually sharp details can stand out from the more worn examples. Condition plays a major part in determining what collectors are willing to pay.

1926-D Buffalo Nickel

The 1926-D is another date collectors pay close attention to, particularly when looking for higher-grade examples. Many surviving coins have heavy wear, making well-preserved specimens harder to find.

Weak strikes can also reduce the detail visible on the design. A 1926-D with a sharp date, clear lettering, and well-defined features can be worth much more than an average circulated coin.

1938 D/S Over Mint Mark Buffalo Nickel

The 1938 D/S Buffalo Nickel has an unusual mint-mark variety that makes it interesting to collectors. A Denver mint mark was punched over an earlier San Francisco mint mark, leaving traces of the original S visible beneath the D.

The overlapping letters can be difficult to spot without magnification. A coin expert or grading service can help confirm that the mark is a genuine minting variety rather than damage or an alteration made after the coin left the Mint.

1923-S Buffalo Nickel

The 1923-S was struck at the San Francisco Mint in relatively limited numbers compared with many other dates in the series. Plenty of surviving examples show heavy circulation wear, so finding one in good condition can take some searching.

A readable date, clear lettering, and well-defined buffalo details can make a coin more attractive to collectors. High-grade examples are much less common than the worn pieces found in older coin collections.

1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo Nickel

The 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo Nickel is one of the best-known varieties in American coin collecting. Heavy polishing of the reverse die removed most of one of the buffalo’s front legs, making it appear as if the animal has only three.

Its unusual look has made it a favorite among collectors, and genuine examples can bring substantial prices. Since altered coins and counterfeits exist, have a suspected specimen checked by a reputable coin dealer or professional grading service.

1924-S Buffalo Nickel

The 1924-S was another San Francisco issue that can be difficult to find in excellent condition. Many surviving coins have noticeable wear, particularly around the date and the raised details on the buffalo.

A sharply struck example with plenty of original detail is much more desirable than a heavily circulated one. As with several other Buffalo Nickels, condition can make a major difference in its market value.

Check Your Buffalo Nickels Before Spending Them

An old Buffalo Nickel isn’t automatically worth thousands, but certain dates and varieties deserve a closer inspection. Start by checking the year and mint mark, then look for unusual details, clear design features, and signs of heavy wear.

If you think you’ve found a rare variety, avoid cleaning or polishing the coin. A professional coin dealer or grading service can help confirm what you have and give you a better idea of its value.

Other Posts You Might Like

More Posts You May love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *