If you’ve been shopping at Goodwill for years, you’ve probably noticed that some of the bargains aren’t quite what they used to be. Items that once sold for a few dollars now carry noticeably higher price tags, sometimes costing nearly as much as new.
At the same time, thrifting has become a popular way to make extra money. With platforms like eBay, Poshmark, and Facebook Marketplace, more people are searching thrift stores for items they can turn around and sell for a profit. Goodwill also appears to have realized what some of its donated merchandise is worth.
In a recent Reddit discussion, shoppers expressed their frustration with rising prices and the difficulty of finding good deals. While some believe resellers are partly responsible, others argue that Goodwill has simply realized how much money it can make from its donations. But are resellers really to blame, or are they just an easy target?

Goodwill Has Caught On to the Reselling Business
For years, resellers could walk into a thrift store, recognize an undervalued item, and purchase it for a fraction of its actual worth. Now, with online marketplaces and pricing information readily available, thrift stores have access to the same information.
Goodwill appears to have caught on to the earning potential of certain brands and merchandise. In a recent Reddit discussion, a Goodwill employee described how their store began pricing Torrid clothing between $9.99 and $14.99 after a reseller brought the brand’s retail value to the manager’s attention.
The more thrift stores recognize the resale value of donated merchandise, the less likely those items are to be priced at traditional thrift store rates. Unfortunately, that also affects those who shop secondhand out of financial necessity.
Goodwill Has Become a Competitor to Resellers
Goodwill is no longer limited to selling merchandise through its physical stores. Through its online auction platforms, the organization can reach a much larger audience and potentially earn more from valuable donations.
Depending on the region, jewelry, designer clothing, vintage collectibles, video games, and electronics may be routed to online sales rather than placed on store shelves.
Goodwill essentially has the opportunity to do what independent resellers have been doing for years. The difference is that it has direct access to donated merchandise before it ever reaches the sales floor.
Related: I Thought I Knew Goodwill Until I Discovered the Bins
Resellers Aren’t the Only Ones Influencing Prices
It’s easy to blame resellers for rising thrift store prices, but several other factors are worth considering. Goodwill still has to cover operating expenses, including employee wages, rent, utilities, transportation, and the cost of processing donations. Revenue from its retail operations also helps fund employment services and job training programs.
The way people get rid of unwanted belongings has changed, too. Platforms like Facebook Marketplace, Poshmark, and eBay make it easier to sell clothing, furniture, and household goods instead of donating them.
As more people recognize the resale value of their own belongings, fewer desirable items may make their way into donation bins.
Should Resellers Really Be Held Responsible?
Resellers pay the prices Goodwill sets, just like everyone else. Whether they keep an item for personal use or sell it for a profit doesn’t change how much Goodwill receives from the transaction.
There’s also work involved in reselling that often goes unnoticed. Cleaning, repairing, researching, photographing, listing, and shipping merchandise all require time and effort. And there’s no guarantee that an item will sell at the price a reseller hopes to get.
While the growing popularity of reselling may have influenced how Goodwill values its donations, the decision to raise prices ultimately belongs to Goodwill. Blaming resellers alone overlooks how much the secondhand retail industry has changed and how thrift stores have adapted.
