Walking into a dollar store can make almost anything feel like a bargain. When prices are low, it’s easy to add a few extra things to the cart without stopping to compare what you’re actually getting for the money.
But the cheapest option isn’t necessarily the one that saves the most. In a recent look at dollar store purchases, AARP spoke with shopping and consumer experts who pointed to products that may wear out quickly, come in smaller quantities, or raise quality and safety concerns.
Here are 10 purchases that may deserve a second look before they land in the cart.
Batteries
A cheap pack of batteries isn’t much of a bargain if they lose power quickly and need replacing often. AARP notes that generic dollar-store batteries may not offer the same performance or longevity as some name-brand alternatives, so it’s worth comparing more than the price on the package.
Candy
Those small bags of candy near the register can look inexpensive, but the package size can make the actual value less impressive. Comparing the price per ounce with larger bags at supermarkets, big-box stores or warehouse clubs can reveal whether the dollar store version is really cheaper.
Chargers and other electronics
Phone chargers, headphones, extension cords, and other inexpensive electronics can be tempting when they cost just a few dollars. AARP’s experts caution that some lower-cost electronics may not last as long or perform as well, potentially leading to another purchase sooner than expected.
Related: 12 Electronics You Probably Owned That Are Vintage Today
Groceries
Dollar stores have expanded their food aisles, but that doesn’t mean every grocery item is automatically a better deal than at the supermarket. AARP recommends paying attention to freshness, expiration dates and what you’re actually getting for the price rather than assuming the lower sticker price means greater savings.
Related: Groceries Cost More in These 15 States — See Where Yours Ranks
Makeup
An inexpensive lipstick, mascara or eyeshadow can be hard to pass up, especially when similar products cost considerably more elsewhere. AARP’s experts recommend being cautious with unfamiliar generic cosmetics and suggest looking for affordable products from established brands instead.
Pet food and treats
Saving a few dollars on pet food doesn’t necessarily make sense if you wouldn’t choose the product otherwise.
Picture frames
Picture frames seem like exactly the sort of simple home item that makes sense to pick up cheaply, but durability can make a difference. If an inexpensive frame breaks easily and has to be replaced, spending a little more on a sturdier option could ultimately be the better buy.
Plastic food containers
Cheap food storage containers may be useful for organizing drawers or holding nonfood items, but meal containers require more consideration.
Skincare products
Skincare is another category where an extremely low price may not be enough reason to buy an unfamiliar product. AARP recommends sticking with reputable brands and notes concerns raised about ingredients in some personal care products sold by dollar stores.
Toys
A cheap toy can make sense when children may lose interest quickly, but something that breaks almost immediately isn’t much of a bargain. Poorly made toys can also break into small pieces, so consider quality and durability alongside price when shopping for children.
