17 Discontinued Foods You’ll Never Taste Again

This post may contain affiliate links.

There’s something oddly heartbreaking about realizing a favorite snack from your childhood is gone for good. One day, it’s sitting on the shelf like it always has, and the next, it quietly disappears, replaced by a “new and improved” version no one asked for.

Food companies pull products all the time, usually because of low sales, rising production costs, or shifting trends toward different flavors and healthier options. But that doesn’t make it sting any less.

For many of us, discontinued foods aren’t just products; they’re memories. They remind us of after-school treats, road trips, sleepovers, and simpler times. Even if they didn’t last long in stores, they left a lasting impression. Here are 17 discontinued foods you’ll never taste again, and the ones people still wish would make a comeback.

Surge

Coca-Cola discontinued the original Surge drink in 2003. However, the Surge Movement was founded in 2011 by three men who wanted to revive it. Coca-Cola brought it back for a limited time in 2014, proving how powerful nostalgia can be.

Oreo Cakesters

Oreo Cakesters were discontinued in 2012, five years after their introduction in 2007. Mondelez International, Inc., the company that makes Oreos, did not provide a reason for the discontinuation. 

However, the product was reintroduced in 2022 as Nutter Butter Cakesters, a peanut butter-flavored snack cake. 

Crystal Pepsi

Crystal Pepsi was discontinued in late 1993, with the final batches delivered to retailers in early 1994. It was a clear cola that debuted in 1992. It was caffeine-free and lacked artificial color, part of the “healthy” food trend of the 1990s. 

However, some say the flavor wasn’t quite right and that the drink was loaded with high-fructose corn syrup, making it more like regular Pepsi than a diet cola.

Butterfinger BB’s

Butterfinger BBs were marble-sized candies similar to Whoppers and Maltesers. They were sold in bags and advertised by the Simpsons. Due to low sales, Butterfinger BBs were discontinued. 

Butterfinger BBs were discontinued in 2006 and relaunched in 2009 as Butterfinger Bites. 

McDonald’s Arch Deluxe

The Arch Deluxe was a marketing failure and is considered one of the most expensive product flops in history. It was discontinued from McDonald’s menus on August 18, 2000. 

The burger was removed from select locations throughout 1998 and 1999 before being completely removed from the menu. 

Fruitopia

The Fruitopia line was discontinued mainly in the United States in 2003. Some flavors were rebranded under the Minute Maid brand. Fruitopia’s sales declined as the decade progressed. 

Some Minute Maid flavors rebranded included Strawberry Passion, Tropical Citrus, Berry Kiwi, and Raspberry Lemonade. 

Squeezits

Squeezit was discontinued in 2001. The drink was created to help consumers drink sugary soft drinks faster, and its name came from the fact that it had to be squeezed to consume. 

Squeezit came in various flavors, including Chucklin’ Cherry, Berry B. Wild, and Smarty Arty Orange. The brand also collaborated with Lifesavers to make Wild Watermelon, Blue Raspberry, and Tropical Fruit. 

Cereal Straws

Kellogg’s Cereal Straws were discontinued in 2009 but returned to store shelves in October 2021 after a 12-year hiatus. The return was due to a Change.org petition that garnered over 81,000 signatures. 

Cereal straws were available at Froot Loops and Cocoa Krispies. They could be eaten as a sweet snack or as a straw for drinking milk. 

3D Doritos

Doritos 3D was first introduced in 1998 and discontinued in the United States in 2004. It was brought back with a revamped recipe in 2020. Some original flavors included Jalapeño Cheddar, Nacho Cheese, and Zesty Ranch.

Altoids Sours

Altoids Sours were discontinued in 2010 due to low sales. However, they are making a comeback under the new name Retro Sours, which is available at Cracker Barrel’s Old Country Store and IT’SUGAR stores nationwide. 

The Retro Sours are made using the same recipe as the original Altoids Sours, but in new flavors like citrus, mango, and tangerine. 

Dunkaroos

Dunkaroos were first released in the United States and Canada in 1990. Betty Crocker invented the snack in 1988, and it became a fan favorite in the 1990s. 

Dunkaroos were relaunched in 2020 with new flavors and a new taste. Some new flavors include Cotton candy, Chocolate frosting, and Birthday cake. 

Planters Cheez Balls

These cheesy, bite-sized balls had a distinct flavor and texture, loved by snackers everywhere. They were discontinued in 2006, sparking fan petitions and even black-market sales of remaining cans.

Responding to fan demand, Planters re-released Cheez Balls for a limited run in 2018.

Jell-O Pudding Pops

Jell-O stopped making Pudding Pops in 2004, but they were reintroduced under the Popsicle brand name. However, the new Popsicle Pudding Pops were not as popular as the original and were withdrawn from stores around 2011. 

Pudding Pops were trendy in the 1990s, but they were not very profitable and were pulled from shelves. The reintroduced Popsicle Pudding Pops differed in shape and texture from the originals and never regained their former popularity. 

Heinz EZ Squirt Ketchup

Heinz introduced the EZ Squirt Ketchup in 2000, offering a variety of colors, including red, green, purple, pink, orange, teal, and blue. The ketchup came in squeezable containers with a kid-friendly nozzle. Heinz discontinued its EZ Squirt Ketchup in 2006. 

Taco Bell’s Volcano Taco

The Volcano Taco was a limited-time offer that first debuted in 2008. It featured a bright red taco shell, seasoned ground beef, shredded cheddar cheese, lettuce, and the signature Lava Sauce, a spicy combination of red jalapeños and different cheeses. 

Taco Bell’s Volcano Menu was discontinued in 2012, but the Volcano Taco made a brief comeback in the summer of 2023. 

PB Crisps

PB Crisps were a graham cracker cookie shaped like a peanut shell filled with peanut butter creme. They were introduced in 1992 with a catchy jingle and animated commercial. 

They were also available in chocolate and strawberry jelly varieties. Planters began phasing out PB Crisps in 1995, but they were no longer available after a few years. 

Philadelphia Cheesecake Bars

Philadelphia Cheesecake Bars, also known as Philadelphia Snack Bars, were discontinued in the mid-2000s by Kraft, Philadelphia’s parent company. The bars were first introduced in 1999 and came in four flavors: Strawberry, Classic, White Chocolate, Raspberry, and Chocolate Chip. 

The Strawberry Cheesecake flavor was the most popular.