Things I Used to Recycle That Actually Can’t Be Recycled

This post may contain affiliate links.

I’ll admit it, I used to be a “wishful recycler.” If something looked like it might be recyclable, I’d toss it in and hope for the best. But after learning a bit more about how recycling actually works, I realized I had been getting it wrong in a lot of small ways.

Some of the most common household items simply can’t be recycled, even though they seem like they should be. Here are a few things I used to recycle that I’ve since stopped putting in the bin.

Bubble Wrap

Bubble wrap feels like it should be recyclable, but most curbside programs don’t accept it. It’s made from plastic film, which can tangle in sorting machines and disrupt the recycling process.

Instead of tossing it in the bin, save it for reuse or take it to a drop-off location that accepts plastic film.

Plastic Bags

Grocery bags are one of the most commonly misrecycled items. Even though they’re plastic, they don’t belong in your curbside bin. They can clog machinery and slow down processing.

Most grocery stores offer collection bins where you can return used bags for proper recycling.

Takeout Containers

Takeout containers can be tricky. Many are made from mixed materials or coated with grease and food residue, making them unsuitable for recycling.

If they’re not clearly labeled as recyclable and clean, it’s safer to throw them away or switch to reusable options when possible.

Styrofoam Containers

Styrofoam may look like lightweight plastic, but it’s rarely accepted in standard recycling programs. It’s difficult to process and often contaminated by food. Most of it ends up in landfills, so it’s best to avoid placing it in your recycling bin altogether.

Candy Wrappers

Candy wrappers are usually made from a mix of plastic and foil, which makes them nearly impossible to separate and recycle.

They typically go to the landfill unless you use a specialized recycling program designed for hard-to-recycle materials.

Tissue Paper

Even though it’s paper, tissue paper isn’t recyclable. The fibers are already too broken down to be processed again, and dyes or additives can interfere with recycling. Composting is often a better option for used tissue.

Related: Little-Known Facts About Toilet Paper Most People Don’t Know

Paper Towels and Napkins

Used paper towels and napkins might seem recyclable, but once they’re soiled with food or cleaning products, they can’t be processed.

Like tissue paper, these are better suited for compost if you have that option.

Blister Packs

Those plastic-and-foil pill packages are a recycling nightmare. The combination of materials makes them difficult to separate, so most facilities won’t accept them.

Some specialized programs or manufacturer take-back options may be available, but they don’t belong in your regular recycling bin.

Plastic Straws

Plastic straws are too small and lightweight to be properly sorted by recycling machines. They often slip through the system and end up as waste.

Reusable alternatives are a better long-term solution.

Coffee Cups

Disposable coffee cups may look like paper, but they’re lined with plastic to prevent leaks. That lining makes them difficult to recycle in standard systems.

Unless your area has a specialized program, these usually need to go in the trash.

Related: How to Use Coffee Grounds to Repel Mosquitoes

Ceramics

Broken mugs, plates, and dishes can’t be recycled with glass. They’re made from different materials that don’t melt the same way during processing.

If they’re still usable, consider donating them. Otherwise, they belong in the trash.

Light Bulbs

Most light bulbs aren’t accepted in curbside recycling. Some, like CFLs and LEDs, contain materials that require special handling.

Many hardware stores and recycling centers offer safe drop-off options.

Electronics

Old electronics should never go in your recycling bin. They contain valuable materials but also harmful components that need proper handling.

Look for certified e-waste recycling programs in your area to dispose of them responsibly.

Batteries

Batteries are hazardous and should never be placed in regular recycling. They can leak chemicals and even pose a fire risk.

Many retailers offer battery recycling programs, making it easy to dispose of batteries safely.

Broken Glass

While glass bottles and jars are often recyclable, broken glass is a different story. It can be dangerous for workers and difficult to process.

Some specialized facilities accept it, but otherwise, it should be carefully disposed of in the trash.

Other Topics You Might Like

• 13 Popular Kitchen Tools That Could Be Secretly Contaminating Your Food
• 12 Food Items That Can Clog, Corrode, and Damage Your Pipes
• 15 Frugal Ways to Build a Food Stockpile on Just $10 a Week
• Do You Really Need to Tip for Takeout and Fast Food? Here’s What Workers Expect